For an algorithm with mature ASIC hardware, the ASIC-versus-GPU question mostly answers itself. Scrypt, the algorithm behind Litecoin, Dogecoin and Luckycoin, is one of those. This page explains why, what a GPU is still good for, and how to check the numbers for your own electricity price.
What each one is
An ASIC (application-specific integrated circuit) is a chip built to compute one hashing algorithm and nothing else. A GPU is a general-purpose graphics processor that can run many algorithms, plus games, rendering and other compute work.
Efficiency decides it for Scrypt
Mining income is hashes per second; mining cost is mostly electricity. What matters is how many hashes you get per watt. The Scrypt Mining Calculator lists 39 Scrypt ASIC models, and their listed efficiency ranges from about 0.15 to 1.27 joules per megahash (Bitdeer SealMiner DL1 Air at the efficient end, Goldshell LT5 Pro at the other). Those are the makers' listed specs, not wall-power measurements. A graphics card running a Scrypt miner is a general-purpose chip doing a task a dedicated chip does far more cheaply per hash, and at any meaningful scale the electricity bill is where that shows up.
The safe way to compare is to price both: take the hashrate and watts for each option, enter your electricity rate and pool fee, and see which one clears break-even. For ASICs the calculator does this from live network data. For a GPU, use the same inputs measured from your own card.
Where ASICs lose
- One algorithm only. A Scrypt ASIC mines Scrypt-family coins (Litecoin, Dogecoin, Luckycoin and others) and nothing else. If Scrypt mining stops paying, you can't point it at another algorithm.
- Upfront cost and resale. Capital cost is higher than a comparable GPU, and the resale price depends on demand for that hardware.
- Noise and heat. Full-size air-cooled units are very loud and put out several kilowatts of heat. See running a Scrypt miner at home.
Where GPUs win
- Flexibility. A GPU can switch coins or algorithms as conditions change.
- Value outside mining. It keeps its use for gaming, rendering and compute.
- Algorithms without ASICs. Some chains are designed for graphics cards. Ravencoin's KawPow is an example. There the comparison is not one-sided.
A practical rule
If you plan to mine Litecoin or Dogecoin and electricity is a real cost, price an ASIC. If you already own graphics cards and want to experiment, or you want to switch between coins, a GPU is a reasonable way to learn, but do the break-even math before you assume it pays. See best Scrypt miners for the catalog ranked by efficiency, size and noise, and how to start Scrypt mining for the setup steps.
Payouts
Either way, a pool pays to the address you give it. Use a wallet you control and check the address before the first payout. Scrypt Wallet is one of several places a payout can go, and we make it, so weigh that. It keeps a recoverable key for each coin and asks for a PIN or passkey before it sends. How each coin's key is handled differs, so read the wallet's security information before you rely on any description of it, including this one. Confirmed transactions can't be reversed and funds sent to a wrong address can't be recovered. See crypto backups and wallet recovery.